HOME + AUTO INSURANCE · DOVER & NEW PHILADELPHIA

Your home. Your car. Your local team.

From a new home in New Philadelphia to a teen driver in Dover, your insurance should keep up with your life. Review home and auto options with a team right here in Tuscarawas County.

Farmers is our natural first choice when it fits. We also have access to additional insurance options, depending on eligibility.

Call Dover: 330-339-3431

Let’s review your options

First name

Last name

Email address

Phone number

How would you prefer we contact you? (optional)Text-message permission is separate and optional below.

Main insurance to reviewChoose your main request. You can add other products below.

Also review (optional): Select any additional products you would like to discuss.

Auto insurance

Home insurance

Life insurance

Umbrella insurance

What state is the insurance for?We currently serve OH, PA, MI, TN, AZ and IN. Product availability varies by state.

Submitting requests a conversation; it does not provide an instant price or bind coverage. Please leave out medical, payment and Social Security information.

Optional text follow-up

You can request a quote without agreeing to texts. See our Privacy Policy.

I agree to receive customer-service text messages from Joel G. McKinnon Insurance Agency Inc. (McKinnon Insurance Agency) at the mobile number provided, including quote follow-up, appointments and policy-service updates.Message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out or HELP for help. Consent is not required to purchase insurance or request a quote.

Lead source — first visitAutomatically populated source information.

Lead source — most recent identifiable visitAutomatically populated source information.

Lead source — current page signalAutomatically populated source information.

First campaignAutomatically populated source information.

Most recent campaignAutomatically populated source information.

First landing pageAutomatically populated source information.

Most recent attributed landing pageAutomatically populated source information.

First referring websiteAutomatically populated source information.

Most recent referring websiteAutomatically populated source information.

Most recent traffic mediumAutomatically populated source information.

Most recent ad / content tagAutomatically populated source information.

Most recent keyword tagAutomatically populated source information.

First ad click identifiersAutomatically populated source information.

Most recent ad click identifiersAutomatically populated source information.

First visit capturedAutomatically populated source information.

Source captured atAutomatically populated source information.

Attribution methodAutomatically populated source information.

More than a price comparison

Home: Review rebuilding limits, roof settlement, deductibles, belongings and liability. Tell us about recent updates or a planned move.

Put your policies in context

Auto: Discuss drivers, vehicle use, liability limits, deductibles and rental reimbursement. Ask how combining eligible policies could affect price and coverage.

McKinnon Insurance Agency office in Dover, Ohio

A local office, close to home

Visit our Dover office at 153 W Broadway St or start by phone. We help customers in Dover, New Philadelphia and surrounding Tuscarawas County communities.

Buying a home, moving, adding a driver or approaching renewal? Bring your current declarations pages and the changes you want us to review. You can discuss home and auto together or either policy on its own.

Office details & directions

What customers say about McKinnon

Timely responses, personable service, great to work with

Kenneth Brately · Google review excerpt about our Dover agency

Read this review on Google

Individual experiences vary. More customer reviews.

How the quote conversation works

Send your contact details and choose the insurance you need.
Our team follows up for the home, vehicle and driver information needed to review options.
Compare available coverage and pricing, then decide your next step.

The form requests follow-up; it does not return an instant price or bind coverage.

Questions before you switch?

Do I have to bundle my home and auto?

No. Ask us to review either policy or both. A combined review helps you compare the overall picture; savings and eligibility vary.

Should I cancel my current insurance first?

Arrange and confirm the effective date of any replacement before canceling current coverage. Our team can explain the next steps.

Can I ask for help without visiting the office?

Yes. Start online or call our Dover office. We will follow up about the information needed for your request.

Start my quote conversation