WE'RE HERE TO HELP

Contact McKinnon Insurance Agency

Have a question, need help with an existing policy, or want to send us a message? Complete the contact form below. Your message will be emailed directly to Joel at joel@mckinnonagency.com.

Looking for a new insurance quote? Start a Quote using our separate quote request page.

Contact our team

Dover · 330-339-3431
153 W Broadway St, Dover, OH 44622

Navarre · 330-791-7866
4866 Erie Ave SW, Navarre, OH 44662

Email: joel@mckinnonagency.com

Office hours and directions →

Send Joel a message

Your message will be emailed directly to joel@mckinnonagency.com. For a new insurance quote, use the separate Start a Quote page. Please do not include Social Security numbers, payment details or sensitive medical information. Submitting this form does not start, change or bind coverage.

Full name

Email addressWe'll use this to reply.

Phone numberOptional, if you would prefer a call.

What can we help with?

Your messagePlease keep sensitive personal information out of this form.

Optional SMS consent

Choose either, both, or neither. Enter your mobile number above if you opt in. See our Privacy Policy, including SMS terms and how we protect your consent. Consent language version: October 13, 2026.

I agree to receive customer-service text messages from Joel G. McKinnon Insurance Agency Inc. (McKinnon Insurance Agency) at the mobile number provided, including quote follow-up, appointments and policy-service updates.Message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out or HELP for help. Consent is not required to purchase insurance or request a quote.

I agree to receive marketing and promotional text messages from Joel G. McKinnon Insurance Agency Inc. (McKinnon Insurance Agency) at the mobile number provided, including insurance offers and coverage review reminders.Message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out or HELP for help. Consent is not required to purchase insurance or request a quote.

Already a Farmers customer?

Make a payment · Report a claim · View your policy · Farmers mobile app

These links take you to Farmers. For an urgent claim or policy change, call the carrier or the agency directly; a website message does not bind or change coverage.