NICK HILL & MCKINNON INSURANCE AGENCY
A familiar relationship. A team ready to serve.
Nick Hill and Joel McKinnon are working together on a new chapter for you, beginning November 1, 2026. Nick will focus on your financial services needs as a Farmers Financial Services Agent (FSA), while the McKinnon team will help with your home, auto, and business insurance.
Nick is still here and available. You now have an experienced team in Dover and Navarre ready to help, too.
Joel McKinnon & Nicholas Hill · A familiar relationship. A team ready to serve.
Nick is still part of your story
The trust you have built with Nick matters. In his new role as a Financial Services Agent with Farmers Insurance, Nick will focus on helping individuals and families with their financial services needs.
He remains a familiar resource you can turn to. This partnership lets Nick concentrate on that work while our team provides the day-to-day support for your home, auto, and business insurance.
Want to connect with Nick about financial services? Contact our team and let us know you would like to speak with him.
A personal welcome from Joel
Hi, I’m Joel McKinnon. I know a new agency relationship can come with questions, and I want you to feel comfortable reaching out.
I’ve been a Farmers agent for 23+ years, and McKinnon Insurance Agency is a Presidents Council level agency. Behind that experience is a team of people in Dover and Navarre who are ready to listen, answer your questions, and get to know what matters to you.
We’re grateful for the opportunity to build on the trust you have shared with Nick. We look forward to getting to know you and earning your confidence, one conversation at a time.
Joel McKinnon & Team
Here for your home, auto, and business
Starting November 1, our team will be your contact for personal and business insurance service. Whether you have a policy question, need ID cards, want to review coverage, or need help finding the next step for a claim, we’re ready to assist.
Tell us about a new vehicle, a move, a growing family, or a business change. We’ll take the time to talk through your questions and available options.
Keep the number you know: 330-247-2181. Beginning November 1, calls to that number will connect with our team.
Your Dover team
153 W Broadway St
Dover, OH 44622
Call us with a question or to arrange an in-person conversation.
Your Navarre team
4866 Erie Ave SW
Navarre, OH 44662
Call us with a question or to arrange an in-person conversation.
A few questions you may have
Is Nick still available?
Yes. Nick is taking on a Farmers Financial Services Agent (FSA) role, focusing on financial services needs. Let our team know if you would like to connect with him.
Who will help with my home, auto, or business insurance?
Beginning November 1, 2026, Joel McKinnon and our Dover and Navarre team will handle your personal and business insurance service needs.
Can I keep calling the same number?
Yes. Starting November 1, 330-247-2181 will connect with the McKinnon team. Before then, you can also reach us at 330-339-3431 or 330-791-7866.
Can we meet in person?
Absolutely. Our offices are in Dover and Navarre. Contact us to arrange a conversation and confirm the meeting location.
What about my policy and payments?
Continue following your insurer’s payment instructions and deadlines unless you receive verified instructions otherwise. Your policy documents and insurer notices determine your coverage, terms, and billing requirements. Contact us with questions about your specific policy.
Submitting a website request does not start, bind, or change insurance coverage. Please keep sensitive personal and payment information out of website messages.