AUTO INSURANCE · DOVER & NAVARRE, OH
Auto Insurance in Dover & New Philadelphia, Ohio
Farmers is our first choice when it fits your needs. When it doesn't, McKinnon Insurance Agency can explore other available auto insurance options, including Bristol West, Progressive and National General. Our local team serves Dover, New Philadelphia, Navarre and drivers across Ohio.
One local agency. More options for Ohio drivers. See our insurance partners →
Whether you're insuring a new driver, changing vehicles, or revisiting your limits, our local team can help you review the options that may fit.
What can an auto policy include?
Liability can help with covered injuries or property damage you're responsible for causing to others.
Collision can help repair or replace your car after a covered collision.
Comprehensive can help with covered non-collision losses such as theft, fire, or hail.
Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage can help in certain accidents involving a driver without enough insurance.
Medical payments, roadside assistance, and rental reimbursement may be available depending on the policy.
Coverage is subject to terms, limits, deductibles, exclusions, and state availability.
What should I have ready for a quote?
Know the drivers, vehicles, where they're kept, how they're used, and the coverage and deductibles you'd like to compare. If you have a current policy, having its declarations page handy can make the conversation more useful.
We can help you discuss liability limits, deductibles, and whether bundling with home insurance or adding umbrella insurance is worth exploring. Discounts and options vary.
Our team serves Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Tennessee, Arizona, and Indiana. Start a Quote → · Schedule with Everett →
Classic & collector cars
Your daily driver and your weekend classic do not necessarily belong in the same insurance category. Antique, classic and collectible vehicles may need a different approach to agreed or stated value, mileage, storage, usage and restoration.
Our agency works with specialty collector-car options for eligible vehicles. If the car is part of a larger collection, we can also review it alongside your other valuable items.
Explore Collectible Insurance → · Request a Classic Car Quote →
What our customers say
Read selected Google review excerpts about coverage guidance, helpful answers, and personal service from McKinnon Insurance Agency.
Auto Insurance questions
Can you help with auto insurance outside Dover?
Yes. Our Dover and Navarre offices serve drivers throughout Ohio. Share where the vehicle is kept, who drives it and how it is used so we can review eligible options.
What should I compare besides the auto insurance price?
Compare liability limits, deductibles, collision and comprehensive coverage, and any optional protections. Quotes with different limits or deductibles are not equivalent. Tell us about rideshare or delivery work before selecting coverage.
Ohio coverage help, with a local team
Work with our Dover office or Navarre office, whether you are nearby or elsewhere in Ohio. We serve customers in all 88 Ohio counties; product availability and underwriting still depend on your situation.
Meet the McKinnon team · Explore our Ohio service area · Request a Quote
Dover: 330-339-3431 · Navarre: 330-791-7866
Explore your insurance options
← Back to All Insurance Products · Specialty Coverage Guide · Request a Quote
Coverage resources
These sources provide general product information. They do not confirm eligibility, the availability of every option through our agency, or coverage for a particular claim. Your issued policy and endorsements control coverage.
Page content updated September 30, 2026.