LOCAL INSURANCE GUIDANCE · DOVER & NAVARRE, OHIO
Your local team. More insurance options.
Home, auto, life or business: start a conversation with people who know your name. Farmers is our natural first choice when it fits, with additional agency options depending on eligibility and location.
See the companies we represent · Thinking about switching?
Dover: 330-339-3431 · Navarre: 330-791-7866
Home & auto help, close to home
Choose your local team for a home-and-auto insurance conversation.
Nicholas Hill Agency customers: welcome to McKinnon
We welcomed Nicholas Hill Agency customers on November 1, 2026. Continue calling 330-247-2181 to reach our team. Find office transition details and policy-service help.
Insurance that's easier to navigate
Your insurance needs change as life changes. Tell us what has changed—a new car, a first home, a growing business, or a family to protect—and we'll help you review available options and the questions worth asking.
Auto insurance
Review liability, vehicle protection, and optional coverage for the road ahead.
Home insurance
Understand dwelling, belongings, liability, and temporary living expense coverage.
Life insurance
Consider term and permanent coverage in light of your family's goals.
Business insurance
Talk through property, liability, commercial auto, and other business risks.
Umbrella insurance
Ask about liability protection above the limits of eligible underlying policies.
Rental property insurance
Landlords, Airbnb and VRBO owners, vacant properties, house flippers and rental portfolios.
Recreational & specialty
Motorcycles, RVs, campers, ATVs, golf carts and other specialty vehicles.
Collectibles & classic cars
Classic vehicles, fine art, memorabilia, jewelry and other valuable collections.
The advantage of a local conversation
Two Ohio offices. Visit us in Dover or Navarre, or talk by phone.
Coverage reviews. We can look at your current needs, drivers, properties, and liability concerns.
A real team to call. Get help understanding options and finding the right next step for claims or policy service.
How to get started
01 · Tell us what you need. Use the quote form for a new policy, or call with a question.
02 · Review your options. Our team can discuss coverage, limits, deductibles, and available choices.
03 · Make an informed decision. We'll explain the details so you can choose what fits.
Rooted in Ohio. Ready to help across six states.
McKinnon Insurance Agency has offices in Dover and Navarre, and serves clients in OH, PA, MI, TN, AZ, and IN. A conversation with our team is the best way to confirm the product and coverage options available for your location.
Dover office
153 W Broadway St, Dover, OH 44622
330-339-3431
Navarre office
4866 Erie Ave SW, Navarre, OH 44662
330-791-7866
Let's make the next step simple.
Looking for a new policy? Start the quote form. Already insured and need a review or have a question? Send our team a message or call.
A local team, in our customers’ words
Timely responses, personable service, great to work with
Kenneth Brately · Google review excerpt about our Dover agency
Read this review on Google · More customer reviews
Individual experiences vary.
The convenience of online insurance. The confidence of having someone in your corner.
Explore our free Learning Center for clear explanations and real-world examples about rates, deductibles, rental cars, trailers and more. Search engines and AI offer plenty of answers; we help you understand the details that may matter in your own situation.
Learn at your own pace, with no form required. When you want help, an experienced McKinnon advisor is available to talk through your questions—without pressure to buy.
Explore the McKinnon Insurance Learning Center → · Ask an advisor (optional)