McKINNON INSURANCE AGENCY • CUSTOMER REVIEWS
McKinnon Insurance Customer Reviews — Dover, Ohio
Insurance guidance. In our customers’ words.
Explore 10 selected five-star Google review excerpts about coverage, helpful answers, and personal service from McKinnon Insurance Agency in Dover, Ohio.
See what customers are saying about their experience with McKinnon Insurance.
Read reviews on GoogleLocal service that makes a difference
Choosing insurance is about understanding your options and finding people who answer your questions. These customers describe their experiences with our team—from switching coverage to getting help with a policy or billing question.
Selected five-star reviews, shown as short excerpts. Reviewer wording is preserved; headings describe the topic. These selections are not the agency’s overall Google rating.
About these reviews: These excerpts describe customer experiences with our Dover agency at 153 W Broadway St, Dover, OH 44622. Review sources were checked on September 29, 2026. This is the verification date, not the date each review was posted.
Coverage and value
★★★★★
5 out of 5 · Google review
I received more coverage for a significantly lower cost, which is a win-win situation.
Luke Heizer
Google review excerpt · View Google reviews
A low-pressure experience
★★★★★
5 out of 5 · Google review
Zack lowered my rate and got me better coverage. Friendly, low-pressure experience. Ultra helpful.
Ian Dash
Google review excerpt · View Google reviews
Making homeowners insurance easier
★★★★★
5 out of 5 · Google review
Knowledgeable on all the services I currently had and wanted to continue to have made switching an absolute breeze!
Emma Toler
Google review excerpt · View Google reviews
Help understanding a billing question
★★★★★
5 out of 5 · Google review
Carson was so helpful getting me all the information I needed and helping me understand what the problem was.
Mya Drylie
Google review excerpt · View Google reviews
Answers to questions and concerns
★★★★★
5 out of 5 · Google review
Working with Everette was a pleasure, he was very helpful and efficient and answered all my questions and concerns!
Kecia Slocum
Google review excerpt · View Google reviews
Quick help with price and coverage
★★★★★
5 out of 5 · Google review
The help I received was phenomenal. Very quick, the price and coverage were phenomenal.
Allison Maggs
Google review excerpt · View Google reviews
Insurance that fits
★★★★★
5 out of 5 · Google review
They found the right insurance for my needs in a short time.
William Donalson
Google review excerpt · View Google reviews
Timely, personal service
★★★★★
5 out of 5 · Google review
Timely responses, personable service, great to work with
Kenneth Brately
Google review excerpt · Read this review on Google
Helpful policy guidance
★★★★★
5 out of 5 · Google review
Very nice customer service and they try to give you the best policy
Donna Seipel
Google review excerpt · Read this review on Google
A positive switch
★★★★★
5 out of 5 · Google review
I'm very happy that I switched over to the Joel McKinnon insurance agency.
debra brewer
Google review excerpt · View Google reviews
Let’s talk about your insurance needs
Looking for auto insurance, home insurance, or business insurance? Our local team serves Dover, New Philadelphia, and surrounding communities and can help you explore your options.
Start a Quote · Meet the Team · Call 330-339-3431
Customer experiences are individual; coverage and savings vary.